Buyer protection in off-plan condo projects
#CoronavirusOutbreak: As Chinese investors depart Thailand, they leave behind half-paid investments in off-plan condominiums. The latest trends show that Thailand’s condominium developments at previously Chinese hotspots have to suffer. It sounds like a temporary phenomenon that should not worry you in the long run. However, if this situation continues, it will aggravate the risk structure of acquiring a property that is barely in the planning stage. Buyer be aware! More at “#CoronavirusOutbreak – Legal implications“.
The need for litigation: Buyer protection in delayed and non-performing condominium developments
Thailand’s condominium market is one of the main drivers of foreign investments in the Land of Smile. The advantage of easy access to legal ownership enables condominium developers to bring to market even risky sales opportunities in the form of a pre-construction or off-plan condo sale. This means the contracts are concluded and partly prepaid before the Condominium Chanote (Or Chor 2) has been issued by the Ministry of Interior. When money changes hands, the construction work has not been started yet or at least not been fully completed.
Presale & flip: Even when a condominium development seems to have a high pre-sale rate, this might depend on real estate investors playing the “presale & flip” game without having the funds to pay the acquired condominium units. When the pre-sale investment is not followed by a re-sale opportunity before the development is accomplished, the whole financial structure might collapse overnight in a domino effect.
Discounts: When selling computer-animated dreams instead of bricks and mortar, buyers (should) benefit from a huge discount (between 20 and 40%) which reflects the financial risk of a prepayment before the unit has been accomplished, the risk that the building quality is below expectations and the uncertainty whether the development will meet the scheduled completion date.
Seven reasons for non-performing condo developments
Reasons: It is rather usual to finance the property development by prepayments made by off-plan buyers. Even if the condo project is announced as “fully bank-funded” the bank loans have their payout conditions that might never be met. The reason for a non-performing condominium development vary but can be typically categorized into seven base cases:
- The developer used prepayments by the condo buyers to meet more pressing obligations for his other developments.
- The developer is for other reasons in a financial crisis, whether self-inflicted or not.
- The presale rate of the development is below the expectation and budget, and, as a result, the financing conditions of the banks are not met or the developer decides to sit the slow period out and to wait for a more attractive business climate.
- The property development faces unexpected legal hurdles and disputes regarding construction permission, environmental impact assessment or other legal issues.
- There are unexpected issues on the site, for example, low soil stability or water ingress.
- The time schedule has been prepared from the beginning as over-ambitious and unrealistic.
Non-disclose: The percentage of delayed or abandoned condominium projects is not published. Newspapers and Internet forums are not interested in publications that shy the developer away from placing advertisements. And no one wants to harm Thailand’s property markets by focusing on defaulted investments. The disappointed buyer might feel pretty alone.
Branded condominiums: Condo developments are nowadays frequently branded by big hotel chains. In addition, they might be promoted through celebrities, beauty queens, and superstars. However, that does not mean that they provide any third party protection. The famous trademark bases typically on a license agreement and the condo management agreement with the hotel company will not come into place before the condo development is successfully accomplished.
The scope of actions on the buyer’s side
#1. Rapid action strategy: If the individual buyer receives a delay letter from the developer, reads about delays in the local press or simply experiences that the construction works do not follow the time-schedule, this should be seen as a clear warning signal that the full investment amount might be at risk. Calmness and generosity don’t pay and are the very wrong approach.
#2. Fact-finding: Instead, a four steps examination has to take place: At first, the reason for the delay as listed above has to be independently verified. It is obvious that the developer will always mention the reasons which scare the buyer least. Second, the legal position of the buyer has to be independently examined. It depends on (i) the purchase contract, reservation agreement, and supporting documents, deviations of the condo purchase agreement from the ministerial standard form (Aor Chor 22), and their legal implications have to be carefully reviewed. (ii) on the marketing material, and (iii) on the Condominium Act, the Consumer Protection Act, and other legislation and regulations.
As the third step, the status quo of the development has to be examined. This covers (i) the legal ownership of the land, (ii) the building material and regarding other relevant assets, (iii) the liens, mortgages and other financial implications, and (iv) the corporate structure of the developer. Finally, as number four, evaluation and economic assessment of recoverable assets and liability mass to be the subject of enforcement is essential to decide what to do.
#3. Strategy elaboration: Based on the findings of such due diligence, it has to be decided which strategic goal the buyer intends to achieve. When legal ownership in the unit is not yet created it makes no sense to request the condominium title deed. Instead, the buyer might request (i) the swift performance of the construction works, (ii) a full refund of his deposit plus interest, (iii) compensation payments for his losses, (iv) the securitization of his claims by mortgages, bank guarantees and, for example, shares, or (v) initiation of criminal investigations.
#4. Consideration of group litigation: There is no general advantage to start pre-litigation or litigation by the buyer alone, as a group, or even as legal proceedings under the class-action scheme. A lawsuit might be too weak and cost-intensive for an individual. A big group of plaintiffs might be impossible to be efficiently managed and only a quick and selective procedure might be enforceable. It is a proven strategy to start with just a few buyers and to accept joint parties if they agree on a predefined course of action.
#5. Governmental misconduct: Another path is to go against a governmental supervisory agency for inactivity, misconduct, and breach of public duties. especially in cases of a stop-to-construction order or similar obstacles.
#6. Never trust a local: Thailand’s property developers have significant market power, especially for the legal industry. They use their traditional influence and power to affect also local law firms which represent the buyer.
Professional service offer for Thailand’s condominium projects from Bangkok
PUGNATORIUS Ltd. is the Bangkok-based specialist provider of legal services and tax advice on foreign investments in Thailand’s manufacturing and service industries as well as property acquisitions and developments. Sophisticated solutions in a complex legal environment. Serious legal and tax advice in the land of smile. For the law firm, assignments on real estate investments are one of the core business activities with a particular competence, long-standing experience, and unique market reputation. Typically, the law firm provides these seven services:
- Acquisition of condominium units
- Condominium due diligence, including rental guarantees, timeshares, and fractional ownership structures
- Development of condominium projects
- Condotel projects
- Massive investments in condominium units
- Litigation and representation of interests of condo buyers
- Legal opinions and property investment reviews
Further information and explanations of the law firm’s condominium support services are described at “Professional services for foreign condominium investors and sophisticated condo developments“. Property legal and tax advice and assistance apart from condominium developments are described at “Legal services and tax planning for real estate acquisitions and property developments.”